01
Origins
West Germanic is the branch left behind on the continent between the North Sea and the Alps after East Germanic speakers moved away and Nordic speech went its own way. It has the most speakers of any Germanic branch today, including English, German and Dutch, but in its early centuries it is almost silent. Apart from a few runic inscriptions and names, the first real texts come in the 7th and 8th centuries, by which point the daughter languages are already distinct.
02
A Unity or a Continuum?
Whether West Germanic was ever a single language is one of the family's longest-running arguments. In the 1940s Friedrich Maurer proposed five early Germanic groups based on archaeology and tribal names: North Sea, Weser-Rhine, Elbe, Oder-Vistula and North Germanic. On that view, 'West Germanic' is a later convergence of neighbours rather than a node on the tree.
The case for a real West Germanic ancestor rests on shared changes that are hard to explain as coincidence. Gemination doubled consonants before *j: Gothic satjan but Old Saxon settian, Old English settan. Final *-z was lost: Gothic dags, Old Norse dagr but Old English dæg, Old High German tag. There are shared morphological innovations as well, such as the second-person singular past-tense ending -i. Old English nōme and Old High German nāmi 'you took' contrast with Gothic namt. Ringe and Taylor (2014) conclude that these add up to a genuine clade.
03
The Second Consonant Shift
Between about the 6th and 8th centuries the southern dialects went through a second round of consonant shifting: English pound, water, make against German Pfund, Wasser, machen. The shift is strongest in the south and fades northward in a series of staggered isoglosses, the 'Rhenish fan'. The best known of them, the Benrath line (maken : machen), still divides Low German and Dutch from High German. Because the shift is what defines High German, its turning point is recorded on that branch.
04
Daughter Branches
West Germanic is conventionally divided into three groups:
- Anglo-Frisian: English and Frisian
- Low German (Low Saxon) and Low Franconian (Dutch, Afrikaans), which did not take part in the second shift
- High German: Standard German, Swiss German, Bavarian, Luxembourgish, and Yiddish, which formed through the contact of medieval German with Hebrew, Aramaic and Slavic
The exact internal groupings, especially the position of Old Saxon, which shares several 'North Sea' features with English and Frisian, are themselves disputed.
Where its languages are spoken
- United States
- Germany
- United Kingdom
- Canada
- Australia
- Netherlands
- South Africa
- Austria
13 more countries
- Belgium
- Switzerland
- Ireland
- New Zealand
- Italy
- Luxembourg
- Namibia
- Liechtenstein
- Bolivia
- France
- Mexico
- Paraguay
- Suriname
Turning points
- SplitContested
West Germanic emerges
The continental dialects south of Scandinavia develop shared innovations of their own. Whether they did this as a unified language or as a network of neighbouring dialects is a central dispute (see Contested Classifications).
Sources (2)
- Sound law
West Germanic gemination
Consonants other than r are doubled after a short vowel before *j: *satjan- → Old English settan, Old Saxon settian 'to set'. The doubling often outlived the j that caused it: Gothic bidjan 'to ask' against Old English biddan.
Compare with other assimilation and strengthening across families →
Sources (1)
- Sound law
Loss of final *-z
Proto-Germanic final *-z disappears in West Germanic, while Gothic keeps it as -s and Norse as -r: *dagaz 'day' → Old English dæg, Old High German tag, against Gothic dags and Old Norse dagr.
Compare with other loss across families →
Sources (1)
- Contact
Franks in Gaul
Frankish rule over northern Gaul leaves a Germanic layer in Gallo-Romance: Old French guerre 'war' (from Frankish *werra), blanc 'white', and jardin 'garden'. It may also have influenced French phonology, although that is less certain. The Frankish-speaking elite eventually adopts Romance, while in the north-east Frankish dialects continue into Dutch.
Sources (1)
- Writing
Latin alphabet via the missions
Christian missions bring the Latin alphabet into use for Old English and Old High German. English scribes added letters for sounds Latin lacked: þ and ƿ (wynn), both taken from runes, ð, and æ.
Sources (1)
Contested classifications
- Widely accepted
West Germanic unity
Evidence for
A set of shared innovations that is hard to attribute to chance: gemination before *j, loss of final *-z, the second-person singular past-tense ending -i, and several changes to pronouns and verb classes. Ringe and Taylor (2014) argue that together they require a common West Germanic ancestor.
Evidence against
Maurer's five-group model and later continuum approaches read the same features as spreading between already distinct neighbours. Some of the innovations are missing, or only partly present, at the edges of the area. It is also hard to find a time and place where one West Germanic speech community could have existed.
Sources (2)
- Minority position
North Sea Germanic (Ingvaeonic)
Evidence for
The three share distinctive changes, most famously the loss of a nasal before a fricative with lengthening of the vowel: Old English gōs 'goose', ūs 'us', fīf 'five', and Old Saxon ūs, fīf, against German Gans, uns, fünf. They also share a single verb ending for all persons of the plural, and pronouns without a final r (Old English wē, hē against German wir, er).
Evidence against
Old Saxon shows these features unevenly and otherwise patterns with the continental dialects, so most scholars treat 'North Sea Germanic' as a zone where features spread along the coast rather than a node of the tree. The features are real, but the genealogical reading is disputed.
Sources (2)